DEAR TIM: My daughter and son-in-law recently purchased an
home built in the 1930s. They hired both a general and a termite inspector to
discover any and all defects. But two months after moving in, my daughter has
discovered wood rot, mold and active termites. The inspectors will refund the
inspection fees, but want my daughter to sign a release form that says she and
her husband promise not to seek other legal remedies. My daughter and her
husband have little money. What should they do now? Joan McN., Dayton, OH
DEAR JOAN: The first thing they should do is forget about
signing the release forms. The second thing they need to do is open the phone
book and find attorneys who specialize in matters like this. Believe me, this
area of law practice has been expanding in the past ten years due to poor
workmanship in all aspects of general home construction and inspections.
There is a strong possibility your daughter and son-in-law will find a good
attorney who might take this case on a contingency basis. This means the
attorney will recover her/his fee once all of the parties reach a settlement.
Your daughter and son-in-law may not have to put up any money to move forward to
solve this unfortunate situation.
As in any profession, there are superb, good and not-so-good termite and home
inspectors. It is possible for the best inspector to make a mistake, but it is
rare. Although wood rot, mold and termite activity can be hidden behind walls
and under finished floors, the damage sometimes produces visible clues that a
well-trained inspector can uncover.
Your daughter needs to realize that these inspectors quite possibly have
strong errors and omissions insurance policies that back them up in the event of
an oversight or mistake. What your daughter and son-in-law should have done
before they hired the inspectors was ask for a certificate of insurance from
each inspector. If an inspector can't prove in writing that he has insurance and
it is in force, you should never hire him.
A great attorney who has prosecuted cases like this one will have a group of
experts who will be able to determine quickly the extent of the errors and how
long the defects may have been present. As for the termites, it is possible they
invaded the house after the termite inspection, but an expert will be able to
judge this by the extent of infestation and damage. The same is true for wood
rot. Severe wood rot in the average home that causes significant structural
damage does not happen overnight or over a period of two or three months.
The unfortunate aspect of this mess is the slow pace of the legal system. If
the inspectors do have insurance, these companies have professional attorneys
who know how to push every emotional button on your daughter and son-in-law.
Their job is to wear your daughter down and throw every possible blockade and
barrier in the way. The attorneys for the insurance company are salaried
employees in most cases and they get paid the same money each week no matter how
slow the case proceeds. Never forget they are always trying to settle the case
for the least amount of money as this strategy is best for the insurance
company.
Be sure your daughter and son-in-law spend time selecting the attorney they
decide to hire. It is vitally important for them to ask specific questions. Ask
for written proof the attorney has successfully prevailed in similar matters.
The attorney should be able to provide references just like any other
professional. If they can't, refuse to do so or make excuses, then keep looking
for a different attorney.
Be sure to ask about realistic time lines. This simply means how long will it
take to bring this matter to closure. Often it can take many months and quite
possibly one or two years. A great attorney knows this, but she/he also knows
how to get guilty parties to cry "Uncle!" as rapidly as possible. Your daughter
needs to find that arm-twisting attorney as soon as possible.
For many years, I have been hired as an expert witness in lawsuits concerning
defective workmanship. I no longer do it because the work is far too depressing.
It was not uncommon for homeowners to vent their anger, frustration and sorrow
in my presence when I first arrived to look at the problems. Although
understandable and expected, it is not the way one wants to start a day.
The slow pace of the legal process also bothered me. Settlements took many
months to hammer out. Those cases that actually went to trial sometimes lasted
nearly two years. Nothing happens fast in lawsuits other than your temper
flaring from time to time if you are the suffering party.