Ask the BuilderAsk the Builder
Ask the Builder's on:

Subscribe to askthebuilder's videos

Air Conditioning
Asphalt - Blacktop
Brick
Building Tips
Cabinets
Caulk
Ceilings
Ceramic Tile
Checklists
Chimneys
Concrete
Concrete Defects
Concrete Installation
Condensation
Countertops
Deck Construction
Deck Maintenance
Design
DIY
Doors
Drainage
Drywall - Plaster
DVDs
EBooks - EDocs
Electrical
Energy Savings
Engineered Wood
Fences
Fireplaces
Flooring
Foundation
Garage Doors
Glue
Hardware
Heating Design
Home Builders
Home Depot Stories
House Plans
Hurricanes
Insects
Inspections
Insulation
Interior Walls
Kitchen
Lighting
Lots
Miscellaneous
Mold
New Construction
Newsletters
Online Courses
Outdoor Projects
Painting - Staining
Patio
Payments
Plumbing Design
Plumbing Supplies
Projects
Radiant Barrier
Remodeling
Retaining Walls
Roofing
Rough Lumber
Screened Porches
Sheds
Siding
Specialty Accessories
Stone
Storage
Structural
Stucco - EIFS
Tools
Trim Lumber
Vapor Barrier
Ventilation
Videos
Walk Throughs
Wallpaper
Windows
Glossary






The Next Generation of Vinyl Siding - Solid Core

By Tim Carter
©1993-2008 Tim Carter
Summary: Vinyl siding has always tried to imitate the look and feel of real wood siding. But if you pushed against vinyl siding you would know instantly you were dealing with an imposter. The addition of foam insulation and new texturing methods has created a vinyl siding that does a fantastic job of simulating real wood.

! Read Author's Notes at the End of This Column !

DEAR TIM: Lately energy costs are quite unstable. Add to that the rising cost of about everything. I need to save money. I love the look of painted wood siding but don't want to break out a paint brush every five to seven years. Is there a vinyl siding product that really looks like wood and offers superior energy efficiency? When I add the siding to my home, what can I do to stop or minimize outside noise from getting into my home? Randy T., Dublin, OH

DEAR RANDY: Anyone who thinks energy prices are going to go down and stay down in the near future needs to wake up. Much of the energy we use to heat and cool our homes comes from natural resources that can not be replenished as fast as we use them. As the population grows and the resources dwindle, energy prices will most certainly rise. It is very wise for you to think about reducing energy costs with each and every building material you choose.

Vinyl siding was first introduced in 1957. Believe it or not, the product has not changed radically until this year. One of its claims to fame has always been the no maintenance attribute. Once you install vinyl, it rarely requires care. But the stumbling block for many years has always been its appearance. For years, manufacturers have tried all sorts of things to make vinyl siding mimic wood. Countless different profile sizes, wood grained embossing, and even multi-colored extruded siding have all fallen short of the mark in my opinion.

Perhaps the biggest problem vinyl siding manufacturers have faced has been the lack of rigidity of the product. If you touch typical vinyl siding on a home, it simply is not solid. What's more, the exterior walls on most wood frame houses are not perfectly flat. Thin vinyl siding and even thicker fiber cement and some wood sidings have a tendency to follow each and every bump and dip. Add to this problem, the fact that most of the vinyl siding products that resemble wood siding have a curl in each lap. This unsightly curl is a dead giveaway that the siding is not wood.

All of these problems and more have been solved by a revolutionary no maintenance vinyl siding that has just hit the marketplace. This product has a solid foam core that allows the siding to lay incredibly flat on a humpy exterior wall. The siding has an R-value of 4.0. Traditional vinyl siding, most wood sidings, and fiber cement sidings typically have an R-value of less than 1.0. R-value is a measurement of resistance to heat loss or heat gain. The higher the value the more energy you save. This new siding is so energy efficient that it carries the prestigious Energy Star label. You will search long and hard for other siding products that bear this label.

The foam core that is laminated to the back of the siding interlocks as it is installed. This creates a solid foam barrier around all of the exterior walls of your home. This is important because the wall studs and the top and bottom wall plates used to construct the exterior walls create breaks in the wall insulation systems. The foam core also slows air infiltration. Outside noise travels through air gaps in the side walls of your home. This new siding is an excellent sound deadening material.

Traditional vinyl siding has typically been vulnerable to impact damage from hail, baseballs, golf balls, etc. The foam core in this new siding increases impact resistance by 300 percent. This feature is very important as your home ages with time. It is not easy to find replacement siding that matches perfectly 10 - 15 years after it has been installed. If you use this new foam core siding, you should not have to worry about this maintenance issue.

Be sure to ask about the trim pieces that are needed to install the siding. This new vinyl siding comes with foam filled outside corners that resemble the trim on my Queen Anne Victorian home. They are very attractive. Wide profile foam filled window and door trim is also available. The curb appeal of a home covered with this new siding is unparalleled. Trust me, any vinyl siding manufacturer that wants to be a player will be forced to make solid core siding. If they don't, they will have to employ the absolute best sales people on the planet.


Installing vinyl siding on your house? Find the best professionals by using my Vinyl Siding Checklist. I offer a 100% Money Back Guarantee.

Author's Notes:
December, 2004

My prediction came true. When I wrote this column, I was certain that other vinyl siding manufacturers would follow the lead of the first company that introduced solid foam-core vinyl siding. As of today, it is a commodity item. Virtually every vinyl siding company offers foam-backed siding or a foam filler option. Which one is the best? Well, price is always a good barometer of quality. Start there first. If you run into trouble, email me.

 






Comments

Rich
03 Jan 2008, 14:00
Thankyou for the information do you know any company that will guide someone who wants to do it themselves?
AsktheBuilder
05 Jan 2008, 06:26
Rich,
Some companies publish a set of instructions. Visit all of the websites of the vinyl-siding companies.
Rose Anne
23 Jan 2008, 05:45
Good morning! I am being introduced to "siding world" by the mother of invention...(How nice of her, don't you think?) Anyway, could you please suggest some companies that offer these high quality supportive siding? Also, how do you feel about Alside Prodigy? I am online all of the time, but I feel like I am going in circles....much appreciated...Rose Anne
AsktheBuilder
23 Jan 2008, 16:26
Rose,
This is pretty simple. The siding market is so competitive that price is a fantastic measurement of quality.
Rose Anne
21 Feb 2008, 08:00
Hiya! I've narrowed my search down to Craneboard and CertainTeed, both Board and Batten styles. Crane is foam backed, CertainTeed is not. I presently have vertical wood panels (T5?) Do I need Tyvek for both, or only for the uninsulated? I'm getting different info,depending on the source. Could you explain a little about how Tyvek (or similar) plays a role in the vapor barrier?
Do you know of another quality Board and Batten line that might offer a wider range of colors?
AsktheBuilder
29 Feb 2008, 12:41
Rose Anne,
I cover all of your questions in past columns.
Dave
11 Mar 2008, 21:31
I was offered a "deal" to have solid core (Crane Brand) siding installed at $6.00 / sf. Apparently they want to do a house in my neighborhood as advertising. Is $6.00 / SF a good deal for Crane Solid Core?

I have never shopped vinyl before, so have no comparison other than what the rep told me.
AsktheBuilder
14 Mar 2008, 11:21
Dave,
No. You really need to be careful of offers like that. Very dangerous.... Look at my Vinyl-Siding Checklist.
Roland Pfingsten
02 Apr 2008, 06:28
I have a brick and cedar home in Louisiana,and for the past 15 years have spent thousands of dollars reparing and painting the damage to the cedar caused by woodpeckers and squirrels. So this year I have decided to bite the bullet and go with a foam back vinyl siding ( since I'm told peckerwoods and squirrels don't like vinyl siding ). My problem is the more contractors I talk to, the more confused I become. Seems everybody trashes the other guys product. Primarily because of the darker colors available, my wife and I are strongly considering an insulated siding by a company called Mitten. They're out of Canada. Have you ever heard of them and if so, what do you think? Good or bad choice. Their literature touts a lifetime warranty, .044 thickness to the panel itself, and a 25 year fade warranty on the color ( which in this case would be a chestnut brown, since thats as close as we can get to the original color on the home ). Thanks for your help with this.. I look forward to your reply.
AsktheBuilder
04 Apr 2008, 15:53
Roland,
Dave was let go for impersonating an expert. My response will have to do. Warranties are only as good as the company that stands behind it. Are you sure it is a good financial decision? What happens if you bought food for the critters? That could be lots cheaper than the outlay for the new siding.

     View all comments
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 







Ask the Builder Comment Help

Helpful Comment Tips: If you need help with a problem, please try these things now before you type in a comment. You could discover your answer in just minutes.
  • Read ALL Comments Before Submitting One: If there are lots of comments that are already part of this column, there is a very good chance your question has already been answered by me or someone else.
  • Read Similar-Titled Columns First: The column above is almost always part of a two-or-three-part series. The answer to a question you may have is probably in a related column or in comments that are part of that column.
  • Read Columns in a Category: Take the time to read many columns in a category. The amount of information you will discover will amaze you.
  • SHARE a Story: Please share any tips or amusing tales of glory! Tell others what has worked for you. Maybe you have a disaster you want to discuss. Let's collaborate so we all learn together.
Don't show this alert again.