Sump Pumps - Backup Pumps

By Tim Carter
©1993-2008 Tim Carter

Summary: Sump pumps can save your basement. A sump pump pumps water away from the house. Improper sump pump installation can lead to problems. A backup sump pump can provide protection in case of a power failure.

Related Articles: Sump Pumps - Basement Guardians, Sump Pump Manufacturers

 

Basements are common in many parts of the United States. These "inground" empty swimming pools have a tendency to fill up in periods of wet weather. If the ground around your house slopes away quite nicely, you can often control this seepage with a linear French drain setup. I have written about these in two past bulletins. However, many houses sit on level or nearly level ground. The only hope of draining water around these foundations is with a sump pump.

The Sump in Pump

A sump is simply a pit or recessed area that collects a fluid. The fluid is then pumped from the pit. If there was gravity flow away from the area, there would be no need for the sump! Years ago in many of the older houses in Cincinnati, basement drainage water was directed into the public sewer system. You didn't need sumps. However, the engineers soon figured out that this water was overloading the sanitary sewer system. New laws were enacted that outlawed the introduction of storm water or sump water into sewage systems across the nation. You simply have to collect this water from the inside of your house (or outside with a linear French drain) and redistribute the water to the surface downslope from your house.

As you might imagine, these laws and the ease of building on level land has created a huge need for sump pumps.

Sumps and Sewage

Probably one of the biggest beefs that manufacturers of sump pumps has is their misuse. Some people buy a sump pump and try to use it as a sewage ejection pump. This is a big mistake!

Regular sump pumps are designed to handle liquids and some solid particles. Usually the largest object that can make it through a sump pump impeller is a 1/2 inch diameter sphere.

Sewage ejection pumps will handle much larger objects. Often they can pass a 1.5 inch or larger object. Don't make the mistake and place a sump pump in a sewage ejection pit!

Common Problems

Sump pumps fail for several primary reasons. Often the sump pit is too small. It is not uncommon for an uneducated homeowner to create a sump with a 5 gallon bucket. This is too small. The float rod that controls the pump can rub against the side of the bucket. Make sure you install your sump pump in a pit that is 18 inches in diameter and 22 inches deep.

Pumps can also fail to operate because of check valve problems. Sometimes a homeowner will fail to install a check valve. This simple device is just a one way valve. It only allows water to travel out of the sump. You install a check valve just above the top of the sump. This minimizes the amount of water that flows backwards into the sump after it pumps. Without a check valve all of the water in the vertical discharge pipe flows backwards into the sump. This can cause the sump to fill up again and you just make the pump work too much for nothing.

The power supply to a sump pump should be a dedicated outlet. This means the sump has its own circuit breaker. You don't want the pump to trip the breaker if the toaster or microwave or TV is drawing current at the same time! The outlet should also be a Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter as well. The presence of an electrical pump that close to water is simply asking for trouble.

Never use an extension cord with a sump pump. Install the dedicated outlet directly above the sump pump if at all possible. If you ever work on the pump or decide to clean the sump pit, ALWAYS disconnect the cord from the outlet.

Checking the Pump

If you rely on your pump to keep your basement dry, you had better clean the pump every 3 - 4 months. This is especially true if your pump discharges water from a washing machine. Lint from your clothes can clog the intake filter on a sump pump very quickly.

If debris can somehow enter the sump pit, you need to install a screen to keep the largest pieces from interfering with the sump pump. Remember, the pump will fail to operate when you most need it! They rarely fail to operate during dry weather.......

Pump Power

If I were buying a pump today, I would purchase as much power as possible. More power means faster pumping and pumping capabilities to greater heights. A fierce storm may create a deluge in your basement one night. You may need that extra $20 worth of pump. Don't try to save money when buying a sump pump, check valve and sump basin. These items are critical defense weapons you need in your battle against Mother Nature. Remember, Mother Nature always bats last...........


Sump Pump Discharge Piping Tips

Pumping Basics

When a specific sump pump is built, there is a maximum amount of work it can do. After all, pumping or lifting water is work. Lifting water against the force of gravity causes a pump to work harder. The higher the discharge point is above the pump, the less water it will pump in a given time.

Furthermore, if you install lots of turns and bends in the pipe, these fittings create additional friction. To maximize the amount of water discharged by a pump, you need to limit the amount of fittings in the discharge pipe AND minimize the height between the pump and the discharge point.

The size of the discharge pipe should never be less than the discharge outlet port on the pump. Many standard residential pumps have a 1.5 inch discharge port. Standard 1.5 inch inner diameter PVC pipe can be used to pipe the water out of the sump.

The Discharge Water

A common mistake made by builders and homeowners alike is to simply expel sump water alongside the exterior of the foundation. I have seen this done hundreds if not thousands of times. This water simply enters the soil, travels down the side of the foundation and re-enters the sump!

Sump discharge water needs to be piped far away from your house. I always install a solid 4 inch sloped drain pipe for this purpose. The pipe does not have to be deeply buried. Direct this pipe to a low spot in your lot beyond the boundaries of your foundation.

If you live in a cold climate, you will want to install a wye fitting in this discharge pipe at or near the house. This wye fitting will allow you access to the drain pipe to clean it out AND to pour a warm salt brine in the pipe should it freeze up during the winter months. It is not uncommon for the end of the pipe to get clogged with ice as the sump water drains from the end. A strong salt brine poured into the wye will melt the ice. NEVER pour this brine into the sump! Salt water can accelerate pump corrosion!


Backup Sump Pumps

I can't tell you how many times basements have flooded when a power outage results from a severe rain storm. However, I can tell you that it is very frustrating and expensive. If you have a finished basement or valuables you wish to protect, then you might be very interested to know that two primary backups sump pumps are available.

The first backup sump pump can be installed anywhere. It derives its power from a standard 12 volt high output car or marine battery. Many of the pump manufacturers listed here make a battery backup model.

Some of the battery backup pumps come with lights and alarms that will tell you the status of the power supply. For example, the Zoeller model will produce a continuous steady beep if the battery is low. If the battery has a partial charge, it will produce a chirp similar to that of a smoke detector with a low battery. Depending upon the size battery and the height of the pump to the discharge point, some models can pump up to 8 or more hours.

If you are fortunate to have a reliable municipal water supply with moderate (50 PSI) to high (80 PSI) pressure, you can purchase a backup sump pump that operates on water pressure alone! The only pump manufacturer that had this model was Zoeller. This little pump can quite possibly get you through an emergency until such time as the power is turned back on.

These backup pumps are not as powerful as a standard sump pump that operates on 115 volts of standard house current. For example, a standard 115 volt 1/3 horsepower pump can almost always discharge about 34 gallons of water per minute assuming the discharge point is 10 feet above the pump.

Depending upon the model you look at, a battery backup model will pump up to 21.6 gallons per minute with a 10 foot discharge height. The water powered pumps are the weakest. If you have 60 PSI of water pressure at your house, you can get the water powered pump to discharge only 6.35 gallons of water per minute.

Remember that the backup pumps are just that - a backup. Do not use one as a primary pump. The intent of the pump is to get you through the emergency. If you get a backup pump, read and follow the installation instructions carefully!



 


Comments:

Vilas
09 Apr 2008, 10:28
I am interested in replacing my current sump pum with submersible pump and batter back-up system. Can you suggest which is best.

thanks
AsktheBuilder
12 Apr 2008, 16:54
Vilas,
Yes. I do that in my other columns about Sump Pumps. I suggest you read all of them.
Andrea
22 Apr 2008, 20:43
Can the float being set too high on a sump pump cause the static water pressure to raise under the home and cause water to seep through the cracks in the floor? We had a sump pump installed on a Friday and we were flooded by Monday. I am certain this was the cause, but the plumber who installed it refuses to take responsibility for this problem. We have lived in our home for 10 years and have never had water in our basement.
Tim Smigiel
23 Apr 2008, 21:04
I purchased a Wayne back up system but I did not want a submerged back up pump. Can I install the pump above the sump water waterline and keep it out of the water? Will it still operate as effectively if it only works when the water passes the normal line?
john
27 May 2008, 22:42
What kind of maintanence should be performed on a sewage ejection pump/tank? Is there something that can be poured down the sink tohelp it work properly?
Anne
07 Jul 2008, 19:21
Dear Builder, I have read your sump pump columns. We have two sump pumps. One runs more often in rainy weather, maybe every 5 minutes. The other only runs when it has been really wet for quite some time. We had our basement finished recently and we want to protect our investment. I have looked at: battery back-up pump systems; a power inverter box that the primary pumps plug into so they automatically run from the battery back-up when the power is out; and a back-up generator to power just the pumps (not the rest of the house) in the event of a power failure. My concern over the back-up pumps that run from the municipal water supply is that our lot is rather small, and I'm afraid that the amount of water that type of pump would put out would rapidly make its way back to the foundation. I don't think we can get the discharge far enough away from the house for that much water (due to a city right-of-way that runs along the front of our yard). I know that there are pros and cons to each system, and no system is inexpensive. Do you have any insight on which combination of pros and cons is the best solution for my situation? Thank you for your time.
James
23 Jul 2008, 08:37
It seems that some of this information may be outdated. There are now several manufacturers of water powered backup sump pump systems, not just the one mentioned as being the ONLY one. There are several models that are far more powerful than the example given that pump upwards of 12 - 33 Gallons per Minute at 10 feet. Basepump alone is manufactured in three models that pump from 750 - 2,000 Gallons per Hour (12.5 - 33.3 Gallons per minute) depending on water pressure, model, etc. There are also Basementsaver, Guardian, Basement Buddy, Liberty, as well as the Zoeller model mentioned here. Water powered pumps have come a long way in power, efficiency, and dependability over the years. These pumps will take you through extended power failures while a battery backup will quit after only a couple days or less.
Kristy Muysson
23 Jul 2008, 18:58
I have read your online columns on drainage and sump pump/backup pump systems. We live in a house that backs on the steep slopes of the Niagara Escarpment (locals call it "the mountain" but that is only because no real mountains exist here!!) The soil on the hill and around our home is red clay, and the sogginess takes days and days to resolve after a heavy rain, despite existing French tile and grading (albeit, in some areas that needs additional work).

We have two sump pumps, one in a crawl-space basement, and one in a full-height basement beneath the addition we put on four years ago. The old pump needs a new hole, since the size is too small - but it is hard to motivate myself to dig in a four-foot height space when the pump works well enough as-is. The "problem" pump is the submersible in the new sump hole. It seems to have a switch problem, as it usually kicks in, but not always. I'd say 99.9% of the time it triggers when it is supposed to...but the other 0.1% of the time we get flooding from overflow of the hole. As soon as I jiggle the pipe, the pump starts and does what it is supposed to do. There is nothing in the hole other than the pump- no debris, nothing in the way of the float...I can't figure it out!

Can a switch on a submersible pump be replaced (as a DIY project), or do I need to hire a plumber/replace the pump? The basement space is finished, and we have had two floods there, which we were able clean up ourselves.

Secondly, we are concerned about backup power. My husband works with computers, and in his office they have what is called a "UPS" - an "uninterruptible power supply"- plugged into the wall outlet, which all the hardware is then plugged into, and in the event of a power surge or power failure, keeps the equipment operating as it should. We are wondering if this variation on a deep cycle battery would work for a sump pump?! Any idea if that should do the job? I thought it was a pretty brilliant suggestion, and hope it will work - it is much easier than setting up a secondary pump with a marine battery!! We will probably test it tonight, since more rain is expected.

We also need to deal with surface water issues - our backyard has existing French drains in trenches, with gravel surrounding them, but the ones on the perimeter of the yard have had tremendous amounts of silt and clay washing down the hill with the storm water which has clogged the system. Three years ago I dug out a simple trench (the backyard was flooding) and was very surprised to find a french drain buried under a foot of clay/stone/gravel mixture!! In light of this situation, am I better off to dig a shallower trench, bury a half-pipe (i'm thinking a 12 in diameter) and leave it as surface drainage, and just use French drains for the area immediately around the house where the water flow is not turbulent?

I hope to hear from you before we set out to make these changes to our drainage systems, it would be great to get an additional opinion. When we hear back from you, we'll let you know how the UPS performed...

Hopeful, Kristy
TE
03 Aug 2008, 13:08
I have a water drainage problem in my back yard, everybody's water drains into my yard. I need to put a sump pump in the high water areas due to flooding of my patio. What do I do? Thanks for your help
Paul Nichols
07 Sep 2008, 09:16
Dear Tim - I am in the process of doing an addition on my house. Is a sump pump required for the basement portion if it is 2 feet below the grade of the rest of the house's basement. Therefore i would have two sump pumps one at the current basement grade and one in the new section for the two foot lower grade. I appreciate your expert opinion. Paul

     View all comments
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 
 
Contact us to Advertise on this site.
Have a Suggestion?

Ask the Builder Comment Help

Helpful Comment Tips: If you need help with a problem, please try these things now before you type in a comment. You could discover your answer in just minutes.
Don't show this alert again.