Standby Generator

By Tim Carter
©1993-2009 Tim Carter

Summary: There is a big difference between portable generators and standby generators. A portable generator can be moved around and normally will operate a single appliance. A standby generator or home generator can power an entire home. There is also a difference in the way they react to a power outage.

DEAR TIM: The last major storm knocked out my electric power for days. I'm wondering if I should invest in a portable generator or a standby generator. What's the difference in these home generators? How do you determine what size electric generator to purchase? Do you think I can install a standby generator myself as I'm pretty handy? Bonnie S., Burlington, VT

DEAR BONNIE: Two months ago Hurricane Ike ravaged Cincinnati, OH. It was a cloudless blue-sky day with fierce sustained winds. My house there lost power, and it wasn't restored for five agonizing days. The loss of electricity shredded the social fabric of the family as if it were tissue paper. Electricity is almost as important as oxygen in some respects. When it's there, you don't even think about it, but when it's gone, you get desperate in a hurry.

Home generators are gaining in popularity for many reasons. After this storm event, I was bound and determined to get a standby generator, especially for the winter season when vicious ice storms can create power outages for weeks in some remote areas.

This standby generator is ready to start up on its own as soon as there's a power outage. It's powerful enough to run much of a regular house. PHOTO CREDIT:  Tim Carter
This standby generator is ready to start up on its own as soon as there's a power outage. It's powerful enough to run much of a regular house. PHOTO CREDIT: Tim Carter
There's a huge difference between portable generators and standby generators. A portable generator is one you can move around. The ones most homeowners recognize are those that are the size of a medium picnic cooler and are powered by a small gasoline engine. Contractors often use these on jobsites when regular electricity is not yet connected.

These small portable generators are not designed to power an entire house. The intention is for you to run one or several extension cords from the generator directly to the appliance you wish to power. You may connect it to a refrigerator for a few hours, then a window air conditioner, and maybe a few table lamps. Forget about connecting all of your appliances at once to a small portable generator. It simply will not work.

A standby generator is a larger fixed device that resembles an outdoor air conditioning compressor. They are capable of generating enough power to keep many essential electrical devices operating at once, or you can invest in a standby generator that can operate every electrical appliance and light in your house all at once.

The standby generators are not meant to be installed by a homeowner. Not only do you have to connect a fuel source to it such as propane or natural gas, but you also have to hard wire the generator into your electrical system. This is fairly complex and best done by professionals. What's more, you need to install a sophisticated transfer switch with a separate electrical panel that contains the electrical circuits that will be powered when the generator turns on.

One primary difference between a standby generator and a portable one is the standby generator will turn itself on when the primary electric to your home is knocked out. This is accomplished by the transfer switch, and can have your lights back on in as little as ten seconds. When the utility company finally restores your power, the transfer switch senses this and shuts off your generator.

Extension cords are not used with a standby generator. All of your appliances remain plugged into their wall outlets. The electrician, with your input, decides which circuits in your home to connect to the generator. This allows you to purchase the correct-sized generator. If you decide to power just a part of your home, the other areas will be dark and off the grid. Think about what appliances and rooms of your house you can survive in until the utility company gets power back to your home.

Some standby generators come with software that allows you to check the status of your generator if you're not at home. This software can also communicate with you or a service company if it senses something is wrong that might cause the generator to fail in the event of a power outage. This allows you to have it repaired so that it will be working when you need it most.

Portable generators can get you by in an emergency, but they are not in the same league as a standby generator. In an emergency, you need to drag out the portable generator, and safely string all the extension cords. You then need to add fuel to the engine on a regular basis day and night. It can be a hassle. You also need to be very careful about placing it near the partially open window or door that the cords pass through. The carbon monoxide fumes from the engine exhaust can drift indoors.

My standby generator produces 17,000 watts of power. This isn't enough to completely power everything in my home, but it will allow me to keep my boiler in operation as well as all the recirculation pumps. My refrigerator, electric oven and many light circuits will also be powered. I'll even have plenty of power to operate my well pump. This means that as long as my buried 1,000-gallon propane tank doesn't run dry, I'll be able to survive for weeks.

Standby generators require periodic maintenance as they contain engines that spin the actual generator. Often you can do this maintenance yourself. If you want a company to do this, they will gladly take care of it.



Comments:

kenneth Golding
22 Nov 2008, 14:35
I just had my house wired such that we now have a separate panel box set up to be serviced by a generator and I can switch the number of breakers I want on this panel box to provide emergency electricity to those chosen appliances, pumps or lights. I have not bought the generator but thought that it would be portable (I opted not to have the automatic transfer switch for what you refer to as "standby" because of cost) and run on gasoline. I figure that 3,000 to 5,000 amps is enough to run the sump pump, refrigerator and maybe some lights. What are the pitfalls to this set up? Can you recommend some generators and do I simply go on line and buy one?
Thank you,

Ken
Richard Degener
23 Nov 2008, 12:25
About 2 years ago I had a Kohler standby generator installed to run on natural gas and was frustrated for several months as it periodically malfunctioned during its weekly "exercises", particularily during the winter months. After a couple of service calls by the installing electrician and discussions with the Kohler distributor, it was discovered that my gas meter was too small to handle the higher natural gas consumption. After installing a larger gas meter, the generator ran great. The bad news was the $1,000 added cost to install the larger meter. The installing electricial was a well-qualified professional, but not that familiar with gas meters.

The lesson learned - check out the capacity of your gas meter to make sure it can handle the added requirements of the standby gas generator, before you buy.
Nse-Abasi F.Ita
26 Nov 2008, 09:18
your newsletter for this week is very rich as it involves a special area of interest to me.
I have gained immensely and will always make it a reference material.
please send me information on solar energy,how to size and use it in different areas of application, like water pump.
Graham Green
26 Nov 2008, 20:29
Here in rural New Zealand the grid is out on a regular basis and we are all supposed to be ready for the next earthquake or volcano. Diesel generators in the 7 kVA range are common.
A 7 kVA motor alternator is way too heavy for one man to lift but they often have wheels and so are semi-portable.
Tim is right about how we take electricity for granted but it is also surprising how little can make a big difference to life quality when it's all gone wrong.
Plan ahead, you will need a flexible cabling, extension leads, multiway connectors and a place to earth your generator. You can earth your set by making a single wire earth connection into your domestic system the fact that the grid isn't supplying doesn't affect your earthing.
Sod's Law is quite clear on this point; your generator will fail when it is needed most. Test it regularly and make sure that the starting battery is in good shape - charge it once a month.
Typically it will be really noisy and make sure that the fumes don't get back inside - they are rich in carbon monoxide.
Finally; rotate your fuel reserve.

All the Best
P.S. If it gets bad I reckon it's all round to Tim's place.
Graham Green
26 Nov 2008, 20:37
Hi Kenneth,
You are little bit mixed-up on the watts/amps thing. The link below explains much better than I can how to size your requirements in volt amps which is what AC generators are sold in.

Best Regards
g2

http://www.crgwest.com/colo_toolkit/ExplainingWattsandVoltAmps.htm
John A. from New Albany, OH
28 Nov 2008, 09:08
This article sounds like it was written by a standby generator salesman. Sure, when the power at your house is actuallly out, a standby generator is a better choice. Of course you fail to mention that an installed system costs aroung 6-8 times the cost of a 5000w generator which will 90% of the real needs for 99% of the population.

If you buy a 5000w generator for around $650, you can make a custom cable that will allow you to plug your generator into a clothes dryer outlet (or any 220v outlet in your house).
This cable, back feeds the house eliminating the need to run extension cords. After disconnecting the main, you turn off the breaker for a dryer outlet (I use my MIG welder's outlet), connect the custom cable, start the generator, flip the dryer's breaker on, and you have power. As mentioned by Tim, it won't run your whole house, but it will run your furnace blower motor, refrigerator, separate freezer, a reasonable amount of lights, all at the same time staying within the 5000 watt running load. Get a larger 15hp generator and you can run more.

And while standby syystems they certainly are nicer when the power does fail at your house, you can hardly move them to your parents when their power fails or easily move them when you move yourself.
jerry
28 Nov 2008, 17:44
Wouldn't it be simpler to just run a generator feed to the electric meter panel (service entrance) where you would install a simple 3-way switch. Plug you generator in to the feed, turn on the generator, flip the switch at the meter box, and you have power to your entire circuit panel.
John in New Albany
30 Nov 2008, 06:47
You culd do that Jerry. I don't know the cost of the transfer switch, wiring. and labor. I use a 220v outlet in the garage and a heavy extension cable for the feed.

So no home wiring modification necessary, just put a 220v connector on the end of the supplied generator cable. Cost to modify the cable, about $10, or to build a 50' from scratch, about $75.

Either way, for around $700 you're
prepared for the next outage at your house or a friends.

You'll also want to store some "Stabil"-ized fuel, and even perhaps a siphon hose to grab gasoline out of your auto's fuel tank.

The power seems to go out here for a 3-5 days every 3 or 4 years. It was the hurricane last and an Ice storm 6 years ago.




Rick
01 Dec 2008, 10:43
Backfeeding is very dangerous, not to mention illegal. If you forget to flip a breaker, you could kill a line worker, or you could blow out your generator when the power comes back on. Also, a power supply source has sockets and the load has pins. This is to prevent someone from accidentally touching the hot terminals. If you put in a standard 220 outlet, the outlet will have sockets and your generator cord will have pins. These pins will be live! Think if that if a child were to get curious and pull the cord from the wall while the generator is running.. or if it were to fall out. If you want to use a portable generator, and you want it wired properly to the house, pick circuits that must be powered and add up the load. With a properly sized generator, put all these loads in a sub panel and put in a cross over switch. Do it right and the only thing you'll be out is money. Do it wrong, and it would be much worse.
Jerry
03 Dec 2008, 02:08
John,

I am installing 5kW solar array on my roof and wiring it in directly to the service meter under a PPA agreement with the power company. It will reverse the meter giving me credits that are good for a full year from each day of use. Simultaneously, I am planning on installing a 3-way switch at the meter box to include a propane generator which will give me that extra option. That will also reverse the meter under the PPA with my power company. So, if there is no power and it is night, I can use the generator. Should the power come on, the generator will merely reverse the meter until I shut it off.

     View all comments
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 
Contact us to Advertise on this site.
Have a Suggestion?

Ask the Builder Comment Help

Helpful Comment Tips: If you need help with a problem, please try these things now before you type in a comment. You could discover your answer in just minutes.
Don't show this alert again.