watch video

Sizing Air Conditioning

Follow Me on Twitter.

By Tim Carter
©1993-2010 Tim Carter

Summary: Calculating the proper size of your air conditioner is critical. If your HVAC system is not the proper size, your house will not be comfortable. Calculating heat gain can be done with the help of the Manual J. Get a copy for your air conditioning sizing.

My friends - the Gibson's - purchased a tract home about 15 years ago. It was actually the sub-division model home. The front of the house has no less than 10 windows if I am not mistaken. One month ago their AC unit gave up the ghost. My HVAC man installed a new AC unit for them. The Gibsons had always complained about being uncomfortable. They thought the AC unit was low on Freon. It turns out the AC unit was never sized right from the get go. It was 1.5 tons too small!

To add insult to injury, the return air ducts from the second floor rooms were non-existent. There was just one central return duct in the second floor hallway. My HVAC man did a heat gain calculation to make sure that the proper sized unit was installed. He has a neat computer program that allows him to do this. You can do the same thing by hand - I have done it numerous times - and arrive at the same results.

One Size Doesn't Fit All

Tract houses often have similar sized AC units. The builder or HVAC person simply does one calculation and often applies it to all houses that are similar in size. Guess what? This doesn't work! In the case of my friends, the glass on the front of their house happens to face west south-west, the WORST possible direction! The blazing sun late in the afternoon cooks the inside of their house. I'll bet that a number of you reading this bulletin have similar situations.

Some HVAC contractors try to size AC units by doing a simple square foot analysis. They use a gross multiplier that ranges from 400 (older homes) to 1,000 (newer homes) sq. ft. of floor space per ton to arrive at total BTU heat gain or total tonnage. This method is unacceptable. If your HVAC person proposes this, find a qualified technician who understands heat gain and knows how to use Manual J.

The Bible - Manual J

Calculating heat gain is really complex. You must use a booklet called Manual J. This booklet takes you step by step through the process making you account for each and every source of heat. Many scientists have worked over the years to formulate the tables, formulas, and values that combine to form this bible of the air conditioning industry.

You can purchase a copy - and I URGE you to do so - if you want to really understand how air conditioning works. The ordering instructions can be found if you keep on reading.

The manual is actually a rather technical booklet, but if you follow instructions well, you can easily work out a heat gain computation of your own. You will at least get close. Don't get bogged down in all of the technical mumbo-jumbo within the manual. Simply take your measurements and crunch some numbers.

Finding a Professional

The same outfit that publishes Manual J also has a new program that will allow you to locate a professional who is dedicated to a high professional standard. They have a new certification program called the Air Conditioning Excellence (ACE) Technician Certification Program. Air conditioning contractors who are ACE certified meet a high standard because they have completed a comprehensive, industry education and examination process and have demonstrated technical expertise with numerous types of air conditioning (and heating) units in the field. They also have a thorough understanding of non-technical and safety issues that impact the equipment in your home. If you want a professional in your home, I suggest you look for someone who has this ACE certification.

Oversizing Equipment

Some people want to oversize their equipment so they are assured of being cool on those hot days. This can be a big mistake. You actually want to undersize your equipment ever so slightly. Researchers at Texas A & M found that air conditioners that were undersized by 10 to 20 percent are more efficient and more effective at removing water vapor (humidity) from your indoor air.

Now I will agree with them to a point, but I don't know if I would undersize my own equipment to the 20 percent benchmark! I would go 5 percent at the most....a totally unscientific approach since I have always sized the equipment on my jobs to match or slight exceed the calculated heat gain.

Oversizing a unit causes problems because the unit doesn't run long enough. You want your air conditioner to run for 15 - 20 minutes at a time. This allows the recirculating air to come into contact with the cold coil inside the air handler. This is how humidity is removed from the air. You will feel most comfortable when as much moisture is squeezed from the interior air as is possible. Short cycling air conditioners don't remove humidity well at all.

Calculating Heat Gain

The first thing you need to do to calculate the heat gain of your house is to purchase a copy of Manual J. This booklet is very likely at your local library and/or you may be able to borrow a copy from a local air conditioning distributor. The point I am trying to make is that it contains 116 pages of tables, examples, and other valuable information that is physically impossible for me to include in this tiny Bulletin.

My copy of Manual J has an awesome example computation. You can see the floor plan of the house and the computation sheet. This allows you to see how they arrived at all of the individual heat gain BTU's. The example computation will allow you to easily compute your own house's heat gain.

The following instructions are meant to HELP you make sense of the rather technical Manual J. Without the following notes, I'm afraid that you might give up in frustration.

You can purchase your own copy of Manual J Abridged Edition by contacting the following Association. The cost ($65) is steep, but there is no other booklet like it. The 561 page, Manual J Residential Load Calculation Full edition is $130:

Air Conditioning Contractors of America (ACCA)
2800 Shirlington Road
Suite 300
Arlington, VA 22206
www.acca.org
Call Toll Free - 888-290-2220


Calculate Temperature Difference

OK, it gets much hotter on average in Las Vegas or Dallas than it does in Chicago. This is important as you need to keep in mind the heat intensity when sizing AC. Manual J has extensive tables that will list your city or town or one very near you. There is a temperature listed that will usually only be exceeded 2.5% of the time. In other words, it can get hotter than that temperature but only for short periods of time. You don't want to design your system for worst case scenarios. If you do this, it will be oversized.

75 to 78 degrees is the recommend interior temperature. You subtract 75 degrees from the temperature listed for your city. This is your design temperature. You will have to round this value to some factor of 5 for all subsequent calculations. In other words, if you arrive at 23 degrees, call it 25.

Heat Gain Through Windows / Glass Surfaces

The largest and most direct source of heat gain is glass. You know this anytime you have stood in front of a window on a hot sunny day. You feel like an egg in a skillet.

Heat gain through glass is affected by the compass direction the glass faces, whether or not the glass is shaded by an awning or trees, the layers of glass, and the total surface area of the glass. This aspect of your calculations is critical. If you make a mistake here, it can be big. Take accurate measurements and be sure of your compass directions.

Your BTU heat gain calculations start once you have measured all of your windows and noted all of the other data. I prefer to add up all of the square footages of the glass that face a certain compass direction. I then only have to go through the calculation one time.

Locate the proper table(s). You will need to know your design temperature, the compass direction, type of shading, and glass thickness. Once you zero in and find the right values, you will cross reference these to a number that is called the "Heat Transfer Multiplier" (HTM). You take this number and multiply it times the square footage of glass surface for that particular compass setting and shading requirements. The resulting number is the number of BTU's that you are "gaining" through your glass. Write this number down as you will be adding up ALL of the BTU's to get to your total Heat Gain. Note the vast difference in the numbers between similar windows that face West and ones that face North.

Heat Gain of Exterior Doors

You now proceed through the same exercise for your exterior doors. You will be asked to select a door type and then find your design temperature and cross reference once again. Use this HTM and multiply it times the total square footage of exterior door types. Once again the resulting total will be BTU's of heat gain from the doors.

Heat Gain Through Walls, Ceilings and Floors

You will need to follow the same steps you did in the above exercises to get the BTU heat gain from all other surfaces that are in contact with the hot, humid outdoor air. This simply requires accurate measurements on your part and an investment of time. Do it on a step by step basis following all of the steps in Manual J.

Air Infiltration

All houses leak air. Old houses tend to leak more air than newer ones that are of moderate to high quality. There is a special calculation that you must do to find out the BTU's of heat gain your house experiences from air infiltration. You basically have to calculate the total cubic foot area of your house multiply this times .40 and divide the result by 60. This gives you the cubic feet per minute (CFM) of air infiltration. You multiply this final CFM value time the HTM value on the Air Infiltration table. Having fun yet?

Latent Heat Gains

Manual J will then walk you through a process of determining some hidden heat gain sources. The occupants of the building create heat as do appliances and light fixtures. All of this - even though it is not great - must be accounted for.

The net result of all of this effort is a total heat gain which should be somewhere in the neighborhood of tens of thousands of BTU's. My own home has a total heat gain of about 68,000 BTU's. Remember, you divide the total BTU's by 12,000 to reduce the BTU heat gain into tons of AC. Take your time with the calculations and you will be rewarded. The entire process should not take you over 3 hours.





Comments:

Pete Gandy
04 May 2008, 20:46
Nice article.
I'll send the link to a person I know who is replacing an outdoor unit.
No calculations at all just purchased a unit to replace old one.
I've tried to talk to him and his helper but to no avail.
Hope this article of your's will at least open his eyes a little.

Thanks,

Pete
Taylor
18 May 2008, 19:40
I would like to disagree about relying on the Manual J exclusively to calculate A.C. size because it undersizes them in my opinion. It was mentioned that they wouldn't be able to keep up for 2.5% of the time and to me that is not acceptable. Most calculations do not figure on people having a party with a lot of people or temperatures being very hot so if it's already going to be hot then it will really be hot in those conditions. In Houston, Texas the Manual J requires that a design temperature difference of 19 degrees be used. It is not at all uncommon for outside temperatures to reach 100 degrees in August here, which means an indoor temperature of 81 degrees at best even if you are not having a party. There is no reason in my opinion not to use a little larger system to avoid this scenario. The 1 ton of A.C. for each 500 square feet of floor plan seems to work pretty good here in most cases and the temperature can always be turned up to 80 degrees if the homeowner wants to save money. Some A.C. guys who believe in the Manual J say this will result in a humidity buildup, but on our home inspections we take humidity measurements and do not find this to be a problem unless the system is severly supersized. Sometimes the Manual J houses have higher humidity, perhaps from a slower air turnover rate since the air flow is sized to match the tonnage and less tonnage equals less air flow, hence longer to cycle all of the air through the house. Thanks for your forum. I've learned a lot. Just thought I could get a little controversy going on this.
claire Quinn
19 Nov 2008, 20:21
Can you tell me what size split system to get for a room 4.5 x 5 x 2.5.

thank you

Claire Quinn
Teresa Harriott
16 Mar 2009, 19:36
I have received 2 estimates on replacing my AC and heat. Our house was built in the early 50s and, I believe, added on to in the 70s. Both estimators recommended replacing and rerouting the duct work. The garage on the side of the house we changed into 2 bedrooms and a family room was built of the back. That leaves us with a house that is long and juts out in the back. One company is recommending a 4 ton AC and the other is recommending a 3 ton AC. One says oversizing is bad the other says 3 ton is not sufficient. We have approximately 2100 sq feet, single story with windows in every room. We recently added to 2 14 inch sun tunnels. Any idea which way we should go? Thanks
Tom
24 Mar 2009, 16:38
I have a similar situation to Teresa. I have gotten two estimates for my home in Florida. My existing system is 3.5 tons. One contractor says 3 tons is plenty. The other says I need 3.5 and even a 4 ton 2-stage would be ok. Both took manual j data and say this is what they used to base their reccommendation. I don't know who to believe. Any advice?
john fox
26 Mar 2009, 11:10
I am building a house on Galveston Bay in Texas. 2200 SQ FT lots of windows, all low-e most shaded. 2x6 walls with R19 and R30 in the attic. Home is on pilings with 10 ceilings throughoutAm told a 16 SEER 5 Ton with two stage compressor, (AMANA), is the right unit. What do you think
LA
20 Apr 2009, 08:01
Hi folks,
I've read the Q&A section and it's wonderful all that I have learned.
However in my case my need for knowledge applies to commercial. My wife and I are in the process of renting a storefront and prepare it for a pizzeria and italian food business. Now here are some variables, we live in the caribbean and temperatures could average 90 degrees; the 2 large glass windows are facing west; the parking lot is right in front of the store and is asphalt; and then we will have a pizza oven, a stove and a deep fryer generating heat. and last but not least, we need to make sure that when those extra cheese pies are in the oven the smoke from the burned cheese doesn't get recicled in the dining area.
PLEASE ADVISE!
Lann
28 Apr 2009, 17:46
I am in the process of building a new home at around 4250 sq. ft. 6" ext. walls with spray foam insulation on all the ext. walls and on the roof pitch, plus R-19 blown in the attic area. We will have only 4-4'x5' windows on the east side, 2-4'x5 on south side, 1-on west side, and 3-4'x5 on north side. We plan on installing underground duct work. We already have a 3.5ton packaged unit purchased and were wondering if we needed(I know we will) another unit to compliment the unit we have already purchased. We will have a soap stone wood stove and some radiant floor slab heating. Thank you very much.

Mr. Lann Smith
Ron Swelters
27 Jun 2009, 21:24
I am sending this email from Bangkok on a sunday morning where it is now 84 degrees and perfectly comfortable with windows wide open and my overhead fan on "low". Late summer conditions in Houston are almost the same as here. I use my 1 ton aircon maybe four hours a week strictly for spot dehumidificaton and cooling in my bedroom. Otherwise I aim for at least 20 ACH and try to keep the sun off the house.

I believe the air conditioning industry has taken America on a fatal non-sustainable path by manipulating codes to encourage sealed houses utterly dependent on 24/7 air refrigeration. LEED and SEER standards and Manual J are part of the problem. Oversizing makes things even worse because SEER rated machinery is poor at humidity removal and humidity is the real problem, not heat.

If as many advocates of the Peak Oil problem say the price of power will become unaffordable then all of this may become a major national mistake and the folks in the aircon business had best be developing a line of fans. A nice overhead fan can be bought for about $25.

Thanks though for sn interesting discussion.
David Freezes
14 Aug 2009, 22:47
So we should all move to Bangkok?
I have a 100+ year old farmhouse that
has no insulation. Heat exits the building rapidly and all that is required for cooling are ceiling fans.
I'm in process of sealing/insulating
however because heat also exits rapidly in winter, and I don't have the limitless supply of wood heat that
the old-timers had. Solutions that work for Bangkok will have folks freezing to death in the southern USA.

     View all comments
*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text:
Security Image:

Visual CAPTCHA


 
Contact us to Advertise on this site.
Have a Suggestion?
Do it right, not over!

Ask the Builder Comment Help

Thanks for stopping by! The Comments Section of my AsktheBuilder.com website are a place for you to share stories about how you've solved a similar problem at your home or carry on a conversation with other visitors. I tried, at the beginning, to be part of the conversation, but there were too many questions being asked and it was impossible for me to keep up and get my regular work finished each day.

If you want to ask me a direct question, you should go to the Ask Tim page of this website.

Helpful Comment Tips: If you need help with a problem, please try these things now before you type in a comment. You could discover your answer in just minutes.
Don't show this alert again.